Articles Questions answered
How do expert witnesses influence jury decisions in Georgia malpractice cases?
- Published November 7, 2026
- No. 54 of 195 in this folder
Filed in Georgia Medical Malpractice FAQ
Last updated: November 7, 2026. Georgia law changes; check the date before relying on any deadline or rule below.
Expert witnesses shape a Georgia malpractice verdict in two stages. First, the judge decides which experts the jury will hear at all, applying the qualification and reliability rules in O.C.G.A. § 24-7-702. Then the jury decides which of the competing experts to believe on the standard of care and on causation. When both sides have qualified experts, the verdict turns on that second contest.
Stage one: the judge decides who testifies
Before trial, either side can challenge the other’s experts. Under § 24-7-702, a malpractice expert must have actual professional knowledge and experience in the area at issue and must have actively practiced or taught in that area in at least three of the five years before the alleged negligence. The judge also screens whether the expert’s opinions rest on reliable methods, following the Daubert approach Georgia applies in civil cases.
An expert excluded at this stage never reaches the jury. If the excluded expert was the only one supporting causation, the case can end on a pretrial motion.
Stage two: the jury weighs competing experts
When both sides present qualified experts who disagree, the jury is not required to accept any expert’s opinion and decides how much weight each deserves. What tends to separate experts in front of a jury is not credentials alone but how their opinions connect to the records.
- Whether the expert practices in the same field and setting. A current practitioner can describe what the work actually involves.
- Whether opinions are tied to specific chart entries and times. Specific testimony is easier to test and harder to dismiss.
- Whether the expert concedes points that are true. Refusing obvious concessions can cost credibility.
- How the expert handles hindsight. The standard is what a reasonable professional would have done then, not what is clear now (§ 51-1-27).
Causation is the expert’s hardest job
The plaintiff’s expert must tie the breach to the injury to a reasonable degree of medical probability, meaning more likely than not (Zwiren v. Thompson, 2003). A common defense position accepts that something went wrong but argues the patient’s outcome would have been the same anyway. Georgia does not allow recovery for a reduced chance of survival standing alone in wrongful death cases (Dowling v. Lopez, 1993), so this argument can decide the case when the patient’s condition was already serious.
Where the standard comes from
Georgia measures the standard of care against the profession generally under similar conditions and circumstances (§ 51-1-27). The Georgia Supreme Court rejected a locality rule that would limit the comparison to local practice (McDaniel v. Hendrix, 1991). An expert from another state can testify if qualified, and the jury hears about the conditions the defendant actually faced.
Two questions to ask about the expert review
If you are weighing whether to pursue a case, ask two questions about the expert review: does the expert practice in the defendant’s specialty, and can the expert say the error more likely than not caused the harm? A “yes” to the first and a hedge on the second is the profile of a case that struggles in front of a jury.
This article explains Georgia law in general terms. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Deadlines in malpractice cases are short and fact-specific, so talk to a Georgia lawyer about your own situation.
Write a comment