Articles Questions answered
How does a Georgia court define “substandard medical care” in malpractice cases?
- Published November 7, 2026
- No. 69 of 195 in this folder
Filed in Georgia Medical Malpractice FAQ
Last updated: November 7, 2026. Georgia law changes; check the date before relying on any deadline or rule below.
A Georgia court treats care as substandard when it falls below the reasonable degree of care and skill ordinarily employed by the profession generally under similar conditions and like surrounding circumstances (O.C.G.A. § 51-1-27). The court does not decide that by itself. Experts define what the standard required in the specific situation, and the jury decides which expert’s account to accept. One setting uses a higher bar: emergency care.
Who decides, and how
- The statute supplies the test. Section 51-1-27 sets the general standard. It does not list specific acts that are substandard.
- Experts supply the content. A qualified expert under § 24-7-702 explains what a reasonably careful provider in the same field would have done. Without that testimony, there is no proof of breach; Georgia does not apply res ipsa loquitur in malpractice cases (Oakes v. Magat, 2003).
- The judge screens the experts. Before trial, the court can exclude an expert who is not qualified or whose method is unreliable.
- The jury resolves the conflict. When qualified experts disagree, the jury decides whom to believe.
What “the profession generally” means
Georgia compares a provider to the profession as a whole, not to doctors in the same town. The Georgia Supreme Court rejected the locality rule in McDaniel v. Hendrix (1991). The “similar conditions” language still matters: an expert considers the information, equipment, and circumstances the provider actually had.
Guidelines, policies, and the standard
Clinical practice guidelines and hospital policies are not the legal standard. They can be evidence of what careful providers do, and an expert may rely on them. A provider who departs from a guideline is not automatically negligent, and a provider who follows one is not automatically protected. The question remains what the profession generally does under similar circumstances.
The higher bar in emergency care
For health care liability claims arising from emergency medical care in a hospital emergency department, an obstetrical unit, or a surgical suite immediately following an emergency department evaluation, Georgia requires proof of gross negligence by clear and convincing evidence (§ 51-1-29.5). In those settings, care that is substandard but not grossly negligent does not support recovery.
| Setting | What the plaintiff must prove | Burden |
|---|---|---|
| Other care | Departure from the § 51-1-27 standard | Preponderance of the evidence |
| Emergency care covered by § 51-1-29.5 | Gross negligence | Clear and convincing evidence |
Substandard is not the same as liable
Proving substandard care is one element. The plaintiff also must prove the breach more likely than not caused the injury (Zwiren v. Thompson, 2003) and that damages resulted. A court can find care was below the standard and still enter judgment for the defense on causation.
A better question than “substandard”
If you want to know whether care would be called substandard, the useful question is not “was it wrong?” but “what would a careful provider in this specialty have done with what this provider knew?” That is the question an expert has to answer, and it is the one a Georgia jury hears.
This article explains Georgia law in general terms. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Deadlines in malpractice cases are short and fact-specific, so talk to a Georgia lawyer about your own situation.
Write a comment