Skip to the directory
Georgia Lawyer Directory

Articles Questions answered

What must be proven in Georgia when malpractice involves surgical instruments left in the body?

  • Published November 7, 2026
  • No. 131 of 195 in this folder

Filed in Georgia Medical Malpractice FAQ

Last updated: November 7, 2026. Georgia law changes; check the date before relying on any deadline or rule below.

Five things: that the claim was filed in time, within one year after the object was discovered or two years after the injury if that is later (O.C.G.A. § 9-3-72), that the object came from a specific procedure, that leaving it there fell below the standard of care as shown by a qualified expert (§ 51-1-27), that it more likely than not caused harm (Zwiren v. Thompson, 2003), and the damages that resulted. Missing the first element ends the case regardless of the others.

1. Timeliness

The claim must be filed within one year after the negligent act or omission is discovered, unless the normal two years from the injury end later; § 9-3-72 does not shorten that period (Spivey v. Whiddon, 1990). The five-year repose does not apply to foreign objects (§ 9-3-72). The discovery date is a factual question, such as the date imaging or surgery revealed the object. The statute excludes chemical compounds, fixation devices, and prosthetic aids or devices; claims about those follow the standard deadlines in § 9-3-71.

2. The object and its source

The patient must show what the object is and which procedure left it. Evidence includes the imaging that found it, the removal operative report, pathology on the removed item, and the original surgery’s records. When a patient has had several operations, connecting the object to one of them is part of the proof.

3. Breach of the standard of care

A qualified expert must explain what careful surgical teams do to account for sponges, needles, and instruments, and how this team’s conduct fell short (§ 24-7-702). The complaint must include an expert affidavit identifying at least one negligent act (§ 9-11-9.1).

The Georgia Court of Appeals held in Oakes v. Magat (2003) that res ipsa loquitur does not apply to malpractice claims. A retained object is powerful evidence, but the breach is still established through expert testimony, not presumed.

4. Causation

The patient must show the object more likely than not caused the harm claimed. That can include:

  • pain or symptoms that resolved after removal;
  • infection or abscess;
  • injury to an organ or tissue;
  • the removal surgery itself, with its risks and recovery.

If symptoms came from another cause, the defense will argue the object did not cause them.

5. Damages

Damages include medical expenses, lost income, and pain and suffering caused by the object. No statutory ceiling applies to these damages after Atlanta Oculoplastic Surgery v. Nestlehutt (2010). If the claim arose on or after April 21, 2025, Senate Bill 68 limits medical expense damages to the reasonable value of the care (§ 51-12-1.1).

Who the proof is against

Each defendant’s share of fault is determined separately and there is no joint liability (§ 51-12-33). The surgeon, the nursing staff responsible for counts, and the facility may each carry part of the fault.

Count the one year first

Check the first element before anything else: count one year from the day you learned of the object and two years from the legally determined date of injury; the later date controls, and a lawyer should confirm the injury date. Then gather the imaging report and both operative reports, which together cover most of the remaining proof.


This article explains Georgia law in general terms. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Deadlines in malpractice cases are short and fact-specific, so talk to a Georgia lawyer about your own situation.


Remarks filed under this page

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *