Articles Questions answered
How does a Georgia court determine whether malpractice caused harm?
- Published November 7, 2026
- No. 132 of 195 in this folder
Filed in Georgia Medical Malpractice FAQ
Last updated: November 7, 2026. Georgia law changes; check the date before relying on any deadline or rule below.
A Georgia court requires expert testimony that the breach caused the injury to a reasonable degree of medical probability, meaning more likely than not (Zwiren v. Thompson, 2003). The judge decides whether the causation expert is qualified and the opinion reliable enough to reach the jury (O.C.G.A. § 24-7-702). The jury then decides whether the patient has proven causation. Testimony that the breach “possibly” or “could have” caused the harm is not enough.
Two roles: judge and jury
| Role | What it decides |
|---|---|
| Judge | Whether the expert is qualified and the causation method is reliable (§ 24-7-702); whether there is enough evidence for a jury to find causation |
| Jury | Whether, on all the evidence, the breach more likely than not caused the injury |
If the plaintiff’s causation evidence does not meet the standard, the judge can end the case before trial on a defense motion.
What the expert must say
In Zwiren v. Thompson (2003), the Georgia Supreme Court held that causation must be shown to a reasonable degree of medical probability. The court also made clear that the expert does not need to use particular magic words; what matters is whether the testimony, taken as a whole, shows the breach more likely than not caused the harm.
The expert explains:
- what would have happened with proper care;
- what happened instead;
- why the difference is attributable to the breach rather than the patient’s condition.
When there are several possible causes
Patients who suffer malpractice may already be ill. The defense may argue the illness, not the care, caused the outcome. The plaintiff’s expert has to address those alternative causes and explain why the breach was more likely the cause of the harm claimed.
Causation is different from apportionment. Causation asks whether a defendant’s breach caused the injury at all. Apportionment, which comes after, asks how to divide fault among everyone whose conduct contributed (§ 51-12-33).
What Georgia does not accept as causation
| Theory | Georgia rule |
|---|---|
| A reduced chance of survival, on its own, in a death case | Not recoverable (Dowling v. Lopez, 1993) |
| The outcome itself as proof | Res ipsa loquitur does not apply in malpractice (Oakes v. Magat, 2003) |
| An expert's statement that the breach possibly contributed | Insufficient under Zwiren |
Causation in informed consent cases
For a claim under Georgia’s informed consent statute, the patient must show an injury proximately caused by the procedure that was a risk not disclosed as required, and that a reasonably prudent patient would have refused or chosen an alternative (§ 31-9-6.1(d)).
The question to put to the reviewing expert
When an expert reviews your case, ask directly whether the expert can say the error more likely than not caused your injury, and why the illness itself does not explain it. Those two answers are what a Georgia court will test.
This article explains Georgia law in general terms. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Deadlines in malpractice cases are short and fact-specific, so talk to a Georgia lawyer about your own situation.
Write a comment